Gosman's Topside Restaurant - Discover Montauk's Best Waterfront Dining

Gosman's Topside Restaurant is an iconic American dining destination nestled at 484 W Lake Dr in Montauk, NY. Revered for its fresh, thoughtfully prepared dishes and unbeatable waterfront views, Topside perfectly captures the spirit of Montauk’s vibrant culinary scene. Whether you’re settling in for a leisurely lunch or an elegant dinner, the rustic charm and relaxed atmosphere invite guests to fully savor each moment.

At the heart of Topside’s appeal is its commitment to fresh, local seafood and classic American fare. While the menu details are not explicitly listed, customer experiences emphasize staples like fish and chips that come with that perfect golden crisp and flaky, tender fish. Patrons also rave about their expertly crafted cocktails, especially Julie’s famed Pain Killer—a must-try that elevates the classic seaside cocktail experience.

The moment you step onto the sun-drenched deck, you’re treated to spectacular views of the inlet, where boats glide by bringing in the day’s fresh catch. This ever-changing maritime tableau enriches the dining experience, making each visit feel unique and intimately connected to Montauk’s fishing heritage. Customers like Mack Vismusic note that while the prices might reflect the stunning location—such as $32 for fish and chips—the freshness and ambiance justify the splurge.

Topside’s staff adds significantly to its warm, authentic vibe. From bartenders like Kenny, who provide personal care and expertly mix cocktails, to managers such as Kate who genuinely engage guests, the team ensures a memorable visit. Guests appreciate the “old school spirit” and down-to-earth hospitality that make the restaurant feel like a cherished local treasure rather than a tourist trap. The genuine interactions and friendly attentiveness create a welcoming environment that encourages repeat visits.

Many patrons consider Topside more than just a place to eat—it’s a cornerstone of Montauk’s social scene, perfect for intimate dinners, casual drinks, or celebrations. The understated, relaxed atmosphere offers the ideal backdrop for watching the sunset over the harbor or catching up with friends over a well-mixed drink and some savory baked clams or crisply prepared seafood.

In summary, Gosman’s Topside Restaurant stands as a beloved culinary gem in Montauk. The combination of fresh, flavorful American dishes, stunning waterfront views, and heartfelt service leaves a lasting impression. Whether you’re a local or visiting for the first time, adding Topside to your itinerary promises an authentic taste of the East End with a view that feeds both your appetite and soul.

Mack Vismusic

10/12/2025

The view of the inlet is vet enjoyable while watching marine traffic pass by. Pricy and fresh: $32 fish and chips, $18 drinks. You are paying for the view. The server was un-engaging, but not rude. Worth a return visit.

Matt Hendel

05/12/2025

Topside is a montauk staple. A must go for great food and drinks. Chef Eddie consistently runs a great operation every summer. Hoping the new owners keep them open for many more summers to come. PS-Ask Julie to make you one of her famous pain killers. The best cocktail in montauk.

John Catalano

04/11/2025

We had an amazing dinner. We received a gift from my husband’s sister and originally thought it was for the new restaurant Bagatelle. We looked at the menu and we were disappointed to see it was a French restaurant. Luckily, it turned out that our gift certificate was for Topside. The manager Kate couldn’t have been more accommodating. We had a lovely conversation with her. Our waitress Jana was amazing. She was so friendly and attentive. She treated us as if we were the only guests in the restaurant. I would highly recommend the lobster caprese. The presentation was beautiful and they certainly didn’t skimp on the lobster. The same for the lobster tacos. My husband had the mussels in a creamy wine sauce along with the steak which was cooked perfectly. It was a perfect anniversary dinner. We will be back again next year.

Samantha Casesa

26/10/2025

I’m so glad the old school spirit of Gosman’s is kept alive somewhere even with all these recent changes. The most beautiful spot to come for dinner for a drink or lowkey meal and such a kind and fun loving staff. Kenny the bartender took great care of us at the kind man (manager maybe?!) at the front took the BEST photo of my best friend and I will solidified a perfect girls day!

Jaclyn Ruggirello

20/10/2025

Topside is my go-to location for a great cocktail, a delicious meal, and the BEST view to watch the boats come in with their catch of the day. It’s one of a kind. Make sure to put it on your itinerary!

Todd Seekircher

19/10/2025

Best kept secret in montauk. The food and drinks are amazing and you can’t beat the view. The staff is friendly and attentive. Really hoping that with the ownership change at Gosman’s that Topside manages to keep the doors open!!

Chelsea Kreps

08/09/2025

Topside is the treasure of Montauk and Julie the bartender is the shining jewel. The service is always nice and friendly with exceptional food. The low key vibe makes it feel extra authentic to Montauk. Never miss an opportunity to go.

Nikki Mardikos

27/08/2025

Keep Topside our local treasure! This is one of our most favorite restaurants in all of Montauk! So many delicious baked clams and margaritas have been shared among friends and family here! When my husband and I got married in Montauk, we created a map of our most beloved places to encourage our guests to visit, and Topside was undoubtedly one of them. We love Topside, and we hope it will be here long enough for our children to love it as much as we do!